chubtastic picture book alert

by marjorieingall on November 17, 2012

I have an essay I have been unable to sell (because it is “too advocacy-ish”) about how chubby children are portrayed in kidlit. If fat is mentioned as a character trait, in picture books and early chapter books and middle-grade novels, it’s almost always shorthand for laziness/meanness/bully-ness/stupidity. Unless this is an “issues” book, aka a didactic afterschool special, in which case it is a problem to be fixed (OMG DEATHFAT FREEEEEEEEEK LECTURE LECTURE CHILD OBESITY EPIDEMIC RUN AWAY RUN AWAY) because the child has to be self-hating and weight loss will turn out to solve all of his or her problems. (Forget the stat about 90-95% of people who lose weight gaining it back, just GO WITH IT!)

I cannot imagine how much it must suck to be a fat kid, already most-likely picked on for being a chunk, seeing only negative portrayals of kids who look like her. That’s why I was so thrilled to find Brontorina by James Howe, illustrated by Randy Cecil. It is a sweet, funny picture book for little kids that wears its advocacy lightly. It stands alone as a BOOK-BOOK, not an issues book. Brontorina is a dino who wants to do ballet. The ballet teacher is skeptical, but with the help of two other students, Clara and Jack (and yay, a boy who likes to dance who is treated matter-of-factly by the text), she comes to realize that Brontorina can TOTES be a ballerina. The last line is (SPOILER ALERT) “Now Madame Lucille’s dance academy had room for everyone.” It passed the real-kid-test in my house (many virtuous books do not interest actual children — this does), despite my children’s own personal skinniness, and it would be a great buy for any picture-book-loving kid with a sense of humor. It should be in every school library in the country.

See for yourself!

Rock on, James Howe.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Marilyn Wann November 17, 2012 at 12:20 pm

How great! Something to round out my Daniel Pinkwater collection…

Katherine Catmull November 17, 2012 at 12:54 pm

I wish you could sell that piece, because it sounds excellent. Also: _Small Persons with Wings_ by Ellen Booraem is a late middle grade novel I liked quite a bit, whose main character is fat and is bullied for that, but the book isn’t in the least issues-y (and in fact is mainly about her problems with irritable fairies).

marjorieingall November 19, 2012 at 3:00 pm

Ooh, I really liked Small Persons with Wings.

Elita November 27, 2012 at 10:16 am

I am a librarian and purchased this book for my library, at work as well as home. My 3-year-old son loves this book and we read it often. It was an ALA Notable book last year, so my guess is that it probably is at most public libraries.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: